When It’s Time to Leave: Necessary Endings and the Church


Leaving a church is rarely easy. It often feels like failure, betrayal, or abandonment—especially when you’ve invested years of service, relationships, and spiritual growth within its walls. But sometimes, staying too long in a toxic, manipulative, or spiritually dry environment can do more harm than good. In Necessary Endings, Dr. Henry Cloud offers a framework for knowing when it’s time to let go—and that framework can be a lifeline for those wrestling with the painful question: Should I leave my church?

The Gift of Necessary Endings

Dr. Cloud reminds us that endings aren’t always signs of defeat. In fact, they’re often signs of health and maturity. Just like a gardener prunes away dead or diseased branches to allow the tree to flourish, we sometimes need to make cuts in our lives so that growth can continue. This pruning principle is not just practical; it’s deeply biblical. Jesus Himself said, “Every branch that does bear fruit He prunes, that it may bear more fruit” (John 15:2). Necessary endings are a tool of sanctification—removing what is unhealthy so that what is good can thrive.

In church settings, this might mean recognizing when a congregation or leadership culture has become spiritually harmful. If a church no longer teaches the truth clearly, fosters authentic growth, or demonstrates Christ-like character, then staying isn’t loyalty—it’s stagnation.

Biblical Discernment in Endings

Scripture urges believers to use discernment, not blind allegiance. Paul exhorted the Thessalonians to “test everything; hold fast what is good. Abstain from every form of evil” (1 Thessalonians 5:21–22). While unity in the Body of Christ is essential, unity must be based on truth. Peace at the expense of truth becomes compromise.

There are biblical examples of believers walking away from corrupted systems or unhealthy religious leadership. In Acts 18:6, Paul left the synagogue in Corinth when his message was rejected and opposition turned hostile. He didn’t stay and argue indefinitely—he moved on, saying, “From now on I will go to the Gentiles.” This wasn’t abandonment; it was faithful obedience to God’s redirection.

Three Types of Endings

Dr. Cloud outlines three kinds of endings:

  1. When something is not working and will never work.

  2. When something could work, but it's clear that it won’t change.

  3. When something is good, but there’s a better path forward.

Many believers stay in unhealthy church environments out of hope that things will improve. But how many years should you wait while leadership avoids accountability, spiritual abuse is tolerated, or manipulation is cloaked in spiritual language? Cloud’s sobering wisdom reminds us: Hope is not a strategy. Ecclesiastes 3:1 says, “There is a time for everything... a time to plant and a time to uproot.” Recognizing the season you’re in is not faithlessness—it’s wisdom.

Signs That an Ending May Be Necessary

Not all red flags wave loudly. Sometimes, the signs that God is leading you out come as quiet convictions or a slow erosion of peace rather than an obvious rupture. Consider these potential indicators that it may be time to step away:

  • Your spiritual life feels increasingly stagnant or performative. You show up, but your heart isn’t in it. Instead of growing, you feel spiritually numb—or like you're always “on” but rarely filled.

  • Conversations are careful, not honest. You find yourself editing your words to avoid conflict, or steering clear of questions you used to ask freely. It feels safer to stay silent than to speak what you really think.

  • Feedback is discouraged or met with subtle punishment. Those who raise concerns are labeled divisive, disloyal, or “lacking faith.” Over time, it becomes clear that loyalty is prized over truth.

  • You feel pressure to appear more “together” than you actually are. There’s an unspoken expectation to put on a spiritual mask—smiling, agreeing, conforming—even when your internal reality is very different.

  • The fruit doesn’t match the language. The church talks about grace, but the culture runs on fear. It proclaims freedom, but fosters control. The mission sounds biblical, but the methods feel manipulative.

  • Your conscience is increasingly unsettled. You hesitate to invite others to your church—not because you’re ashamed of the gospel, but because you’re unsure of the environment they’d walk into.

  • The Spirit seems to be stirring restlessness in your soul. It’s not rooted in bitterness or rebellion, but a gentle, persistent sense that “this isn’t where you’re meant to stay.”

  • You are no longer able to worship, serve, or participate with authenticity. You find yourself going through the motions—or quietly withdrawing—because your convictions no longer align with the church’s direction.

  • You are constantly spiritualizing dysfunction in order to stay. You rationalize problems with phrases like “no church is perfect” or “God calls us to suffer,” even though what you’re experiencing isn’t healthy suffering, but spiritual erosion.

  • You dread Sunday. Instead of looking forward to gathering with the Body of Christ, you feel a weight of resistance or emotional exhaustion at the thought of returning.

In Matthew 10:14, Jesus instructed His disciples that if a place would not receive their message, they were to shake the dust off their feet and move on. That doesn’t mean we abandon community lightly, but it does show that sometimes walking away is part of faithful witness.

Walking Away with Grace

Leaving a church doesn’t mean leaving the Church. The global Body of Christ is bigger than any one building, denomination, or leadership team. Scripture paints the Church as a living body with many parts (1 Corinthians 12:12–27), and sometimes God calls us to move to a different part of His Body for our growth and His purposes.

Dr. Cloud encourages believers to end things well—without bitterness or unnecessary drama, but also with courage and clarity. Ephesians 4:15 tells us to speak the truth in love. That includes being honest with yourself and others about why you’re leaving.

Forgiveness is essential, even when you're the one who was hurt. Hebrews 12:15 warns us not to let a root of bitterness grow. Letting go means entrusting your pain to God, allowing Him to bring justice and healing in His time.

You’re Not Alone

If you’re in this space, you’re not alone. Many believers are quietly carrying the grief of spiritual disillusionment. Sometimes, God calls us to leave not because we’re faithless, but because we’re faithful—to Him, to truth, and to the call to grow in maturity. Isaiah 43:19 says, “See, I am doing a new thing! Now it springs up; do you not perceive it?”Necessary endings are not the end of your story—they may be the beginning of something sacred and new.

Conclusion

Leaving a church can feel like death, but God specializes in resurrection. Necessary endings—when done with humility, prayer, and courage—can be one of the most spiritually formative experiences of your life. If you're wrestling with the decision to stay or go, take heart. The Lord is your Shepherd (Psalm 23), and He leads His people faithfully—even through endings.


Rooted in Jesus Grace,

Mara Wellspring 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Charisma Trap: The Hidden Costs of Visionary Leadership

Image
In today’s church culture, charisma and vision often take center stage. Leaders with magnetic personalities, eloquent communication, and a bold sense of mission can generate impressive momentum. Churches grow. Excitement builds. People feel part of something significant. But what happens when that vision, however compelling, becomes the foundation of the church’s identity? What if the very qualities that spark growth also plant the seeds of dysfunction? The Allure of a Good Vision In many churches, especially larger or non-denominational ones, there’s a sense that  this  church has discovered a more effective, more world-changing expression of Christianity. Vision nights are filled with language like,  “We’re here to transform our city”  or  “This church is the hope of the world.” And the vision often includes genuinely good things: attend prayer meetings, join a small group, serve faithfully, build healthy spiritual rhythms. Who could argue with that? These are...
Read more

About This Blog

Image
When the church breaks your trust, but not your faith.  I never expected to be the kind of person who would write about church hurt. I believed in accountability. In asking hard questions. In searching the Scriptures. I wasn’t reckless with my trust. But sometimes even caution doesn’t protect you from spiritual abuse—especially when it’s wrapped in charisma, Scripture, and good intentions. This blog is my quiet place to process. To name things I can’t say out loud. To speak gently and truthfully about what happens when church becomes unsafe—and how to imagine something better. I’m writing not as an expert, but as someone who has lived through the slow unraveling of trust in a place that once felt like home. Someone who still loves Jesus but can no longer unsee what I’ve seen. Someone learning that safety, honesty, and healthy community are not too much to ask from the Body of Christ. If you’re wrestling with your own questions… If you’ve felt the ache of betrayal in a place that wa...
Read more

About Me

Image
  A Journey of Healing and Truth: My Story of Leaving an Unhealthy Church I have been a Christian my entire life. For as long as I can remember, I’ve been a part of the church — volunteering in countless capacities, raising my kids in its embrace, going on mission trips, serving in camp ministry, and being a small group leader. I thought I had it all figured out. My life in church was good — I was popular, surrounded by church friends, and doing what I thought was the right thing. Then, COVID hit. Everything changed. The church shut down, and with it, so did everything I thought I knew about church life. For a while, everything was taken away. The activities, the meetings, the fellowship — it all disappeared. But through it all, I still had Jesus. I still sought Him. And in my seeking, my eyes began to open. For the first time, I started seeing the church differently. I began to see the church as an institution. I began to notice how polarized people had become. There was a disturb...
Read more