Levels of Reconciliation: When “Peace” Doesn’t All Look the Same Part 6


Conflict is an unavoidable part of human relationships — even in Christian community. Whether it’s a disagreement with a friend, a betrayal by a family member, or hurt within the church, we all face situations where reconciliation is needed. But what exactly does reconciliation look like?

In The Peacemaker, Ken Sande wisely points out something many overlook: not all reconciliation is the same. In our pursuit of peace, we must understand that restoration can take different forms depending on repentance, safety, trust, and spiritual maturity. Let’s explore the three levels of reconciliation and how each can honor God and reflect His wisdom.

1. Full Reconciliation

This is the ideal.

In full reconciliation, the relationship is not only repaired — it is restored to its former closeness or even improved. Trust, once broken, is rebuilt through time, honesty, and mutual grace. This level of reconciliation is marked by open communication, heartfelt repentance, forgiveness, and a shared commitment to walk in truth.

Example: A long-time friendship suffers a painful rift — perhaps from harsh words, misunderstandings, or differing life choices. But after hard conversations, confession, and real forgiveness, the bond is mended. Both friends take ownership, extend grace, and come away stronger than before.

This level requires:

  • Genuine repentance from both parties
  • A willingness to forgive fully
  • Consistent follow-through to rebuild trust
  • Mutual humility and transparency

This is the kind of restoration we celebrate — it reflects the heart of God, who reconciles us fully to Himself through Christ (2 Corinthians 5:18). But in a broken world, full reconciliation may not always be possible.

2. Partial Reconciliation

This is peace with boundaries.

Sometimes, you’ve forgiven, and there’s some level of peace — but the closeness isn’t restored, and that’s okay. Partial reconciliation means the hostility is resolved, but either due to lingering trust issues or ongoing differences, the relationship operates with caution.

Example: A relative repeatedly violated your boundaries over the years. After a serious conversation, they express regret. You forgive them — but you also choose to limit contact to preserve your well-being. You’re kind, respectful, and not harboring bitterness — but you no longer trust them with personal matters.

Partial reconciliation might be appropriate when:

  • The other person is repentant, but change is slow or inconsistent
  • Trust was seriously broken and needs time (or may never fully return)
  • There’s an ongoing mismatch in values, personalities, or communication
  • You want to protect yourself or others from future harm

This level still honors Christ. It reflects Romans 12:18, which says: “If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone.” Peace doesn’t always mean closeness — it may mean respectful distance.

3. Deferred or No Reconciliation (Yet)

This is forgiveness without relationship.

Sometimes reconciliation is not currently possible. Perhaps the person is unrepentant, defensive, or continuing in harmful behavior. You may forgive them internally — releasing the bitterness and entrusting justice to God (Romans 12:19) — but you do not reenter the relationship.

Example: A former leader emotionally manipulated and mistreated you. You’ve processed the hurt and forgiven them from the heart — but they’ve never apologized or acknowledged the damage. They continue to lead in toxic ways. Out of wisdom, you choose not to resume any personal or spiritual relationship.

This is not bitterness. This is discernment and stewardship of your safety and well-being.

Reasons for deferred reconciliation:

  • The person is not safe (abusive, manipulative, controlling)
  • They are unwilling to engage honestly or take ownership
  • Trust has been shattered and no evidence of change is present

Forgiveness is not the same as reconciliation. Jesus forgave His enemies from the cross, but He didn’t enter into restored relationship with those who continued to reject Him. Similarly, we can forgive without reconciling — at least for now.

Navigating the Differences with Wisdom

Recognizing these levels frees us from false guilt and pressure to pretend everything is okay when it’s not. It helps us forgive without minimizing harm. It allows us to seek peace while respecting healthy boundaries.

Not all stories end with a bow tied neatly on top. And that’s okay.

Here are a few practical reminders:

  • Forgiveness is always required (Matthew 18:21–22). Reconciliation is not.
  • Rebuilding trust takes time and consistent fruit.
  • You can be kind without being close.
  • God is just — and sometimes, letting go is a way of entrusting the situation to Him.

Final Thought

In God’s economy, peace matters. But peace that comes at the expense of truth and safety is not biblical peace. By understanding these levels of reconciliation, we can honor God, protect ourselves wisely, and engage others with both grace and truth.

Sometimes reconciliation is full and beautiful. Other times, it’s partial — or deferred indefinitely. In all things,let love, humility, and wisdom guide your path.

“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God.” — Matthew 5:9

 

 

Inspired by Ken Sande’s The Peacemaker—a timeless guide to living out the gospel of peace in everyday life.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Charisma Trap: The Hidden Costs of Visionary Leadership

Image
In today’s church culture, charisma and vision often take center stage. Leaders with magnetic personalities, eloquent communication, and a bold sense of mission can generate impressive momentum. Churches grow. Excitement builds. People feel part of something significant. But what happens when that vision, however compelling, becomes the foundation of the church’s identity? What if the very qualities that spark growth also plant the seeds of dysfunction? The Allure of a Good Vision In many churches, especially larger or non-denominational ones, there’s a sense that  this  church has discovered a more effective, more world-changing expression of Christianity. Vision nights are filled with language like,  “We’re here to transform our city”  or  “This church is the hope of the world.” And the vision often includes genuinely good things: attend prayer meetings, join a small group, serve faithfully, build healthy spiritual rhythms. Who could argue with that? These are...
Read more

About Me

Image
  A Journey of Healing and Truth: My Story of Leaving an Unhealthy Church I have been a Christian my entire life. For as long as I can remember, I’ve been a part of the church — volunteering in countless capacities, raising my kids in its embrace, going on mission trips, serving in camp ministry, and being a small group leader. I thought I had it all figured out. My life in church was good — I was popular, surrounded by church friends, and doing what I thought was the right thing. Then, COVID hit. Everything changed. The church shut down, and with it, so did everything I thought I knew about church life. For a while, everything was taken away. The activities, the meetings, the fellowship — it all disappeared. But through it all, I still had Jesus. I still sought Him. And in my seeking, my eyes began to open. For the first time, I started seeing the church differently. I began to see the church as an institution. I began to notice how polarized people had become. There was a disturb...
Read more

About This Blog

Image
When the church breaks your trust, but not your faith.  I never expected to be the kind of person who would write about church hurt. I believed in accountability. In asking hard questions. In searching the Scriptures. I wasn’t reckless with my trust. But sometimes even caution doesn’t protect you from spiritual abuse—especially when it’s wrapped in charisma, Scripture, and good intentions. This blog is my quiet place to process. To name things I can’t say out loud. To speak gently and truthfully about what happens when church becomes unsafe—and how to imagine something better. I’m writing not as an expert, but as someone who has lived through the slow unraveling of trust in a place that once felt like home. Someone who still loves Jesus but can no longer unsee what I’ve seen. Someone learning that safety, honesty, and healthy community are not too much to ask from the Body of Christ. If you’re wrestling with your own questions… If you’ve felt the ache of betrayal in a place that wa...
Read more